Readable beats clever
A visitor should be able to look at a slug and understand the basic topic of the page. Short, direct wording usually works better than compressed jargon, filler words, or unnecessary numbers.
If a link feels clear at a glance, it is doing its job well.
Consistency matters across the site
A site looks more professional when slugs follow the same style. Lowercase wording, simple separators, and predictable cleanup rules reduce friction for both users and publishers.
Consistency also makes content management easier as the site grows.
Shorter is usually better when meaning stays intact
Long slugs are not automatically bad, but they often include extra words that add little value. If you can remove filler while keeping the page meaning clear, the result usually feels cleaner.
That matters for both usability and ongoing site maintenance.
A generator gives you a starting point
Slug generators are most useful when they remove repetitive cleanup work and give you a clean first draft. The final editorial choice may still need a human decision for important public pages.
That balance helps you move faster without losing quality.